
Principle No. 6 The Agreement Principle
By Clifton L. Fowler
Taken from Grace and Truth Magazine 1923
| 
												
												For nearly two millenniums the 
												enemies of the Word of God have determinedly 
												contended that the Bible abounds in 
												contradictions, discrepancies, inconsistencies and 
												inaccuracies. The first great 
												writer taking the positions of 
												so-called modernism was 
												Porphyry. He wrote in the latter part of 
												the third century, and although his mind had never been 
												instructed in the “newer conceptions of this enlightened 
												age,” he took the same positions, to a very large extent, 
												which are now taken by the modernist. His method of attack 
												upon the Word of God. was identical with modernism. He 
												wrote fifteen books against the Bible taking the 
												Pentateuch, Daniel and many of the other sections which 
												are the favorite battle grounds of the followers of 
												Shailer Matthews, George “Albert Coe, Harry Emerson Fosdick, et al. The Christians of that early day recognized Porphyry as a wicked blasphemer and classified his writings 
												as satanic. Jerome calls him a “rabid dog against Christ.” The claim that the Bible contradicts itself is still 
												heard. Books are written with such titles as “One Thousand Contradictions from the Bible,” and surface inconsistencies and alleged inaccuracies are paraded before the minds of the untrained as though they were incontrovertible contradictions. The fact of the matter is, not one supposed inaccuracy in the Bible has ever been demonstrated to actually exist. They have all been shown to have been resting upon the flimsy basis of a false transcription, or an 
												interpretation that is repugnant 
												to the balance of Scripture. As has been frequently said in 
												this series of studies on the Eighteen Principles of 
												Divine Revelation, it is not our purpose in these discussions 
												to prove the inspiration of the Scriptures. We are simply 
												seeking to adduce from the Word of God itself proof of 
												existence of underlying principles of Divine Revelation. 
												The “Higher Critic” is constantly boasting that his 
												conclusions are based upon internal evidence. We accept his 
												challenge and submit the inescapable and indubitable 
												demonstration that the Fighteen Principles rest upon 
												nothing more nor less than a convincing array of internal 
												evidence. The plenary and verbal inspiration of God's Holy 
												Word is constantly assumed. The definition of the Agreement 
												Principle is: 
												THE AGREEMENT PRINCIPLE IS THAT 
												PRINCIPLE OF DIVINE REVELATION 
												
												 
													(a) Under which the truthfulness 
												and faithfulness of God become His 
												guarantee that He will not set forth any 
												passage in His Word which contradicts any 
												other passage. So common has unfaithfulness and 
												disloyalty become among men that their conception 
												of God has become a reflection of their own wicked 
												and degraded condition. ‘The modernist unhesitatingly 
												accuses the Lord Jesus Christ of accommodating Himself to the 
												ignorance of the people of His day in many points in His 
												teaching. The Saviour is frankly accredited with 
												“knowing better” but He employed tact in order that He 
												should not be guilty of antagonizing those whom He was 
												seeking to teach. ‘This abominable defamation of the moral character of our Lord and Saviour, Jesus Christ, is quite generally held by those who have embraced the fallacies of modern thought. Furthermore, the modernist denies the accuracy of the narratives pertaining to the miracles and fancies that he sees on almost every page of the Old Testament contradictions and discrepancies, some minor and some of major importance. To entertain these ideas is to accuse 
												God of unspeakable falsehood and to deny His faithfulness to His people. The faithfulness of God is declared over and over again in the Word: 
													“Forever, O Lord, Thy Word is settled in heaven, ‘Thy faithfulness is unto all generations.” (Ps, 119;89-90.) 
													
												 If God is faithful, and God has 
												settled His “Word,” then it may be declared with 
												assurance there is no unfaithfulness or falsehood in that 
												Word. Because God is faithful He cannot disagree with 
												Himself. Because God is faithful the Book which purports 
												to be God’s Book cannot contain discrepancies and 
												contradictions. If discrepancies and contradictions are 
												demonstrated to exist in the Bible, then one of two things 
												becomes inescapably certain, —cither the Bible is not God’s 
												Book for God is faithful, ‘or else the Bible is God's Book 
												and God is not faithful, We unhesitatingly repudiate both 
												of these conclusions and accept the ultimatum of 
												inspiration,—God is faithful, 
												and the Bible is His changelessly 
												harmonious Book. If God is faithful then God does 
												not falsify. To this the Scriptures bear witness: “God is not man that He should 
												LIE.” (Num. 23:19.) 
												 “He is the Rock, His work is 
												perfect, * * * a God of TRUTH and without iniquity; 
												just and right is He.” (Deut. 32:4.) “The Strength of Israel WILL 
												NOT LIE.” (1 Sam. 15:29.) “The Word of the Lord is 
												RIGHT.” (Ps. 33:4.) 
												“Let God be TRUE but every man a 
												liar,” (Rom. 3:4) 
												“In hope of eternal life which 
												GOD THAT CANNOT LIE, promised 
												before the world began.” (Titus 
												1:2) |“and they cried with a loud 
												voice, saying, How long, O Lord, HOLY AND TRUE.” 
												(Rev. 6:10.) “I am the Way, the TRUTH, and 
												the Life.” (Jno. 14:6.) God is not a liar. God does not 
												contradict Himself. He cannot contradict Himself and 
												still be GOD. God does not tell us a beautiful 
												narrative of an astonishing 
												miracle in order to produce dramatic 
												effect and then let it be discovered a few thousand years 
												later that He had put a ‘rather clever one over on His 
												trusting and credulous people. ‘The positions of modernism 
												are an insult to God and a repudiation of His Word. 
												Our God is Truth! 
												 The truthfulness and 
												faithfulness of God become His ‘guarantee that He will not 
												allow to creep into His Divine ‘revelation passages the true 
												meaning of which is repugant to any other passage. ‘The 
												Agreement Principle is that principle of Divine 
												Revelation under which God never disagrees with Himself. If 
												God were to say any‘thing in Genesis which He later 
												contradicts in Revelation ‘His faithfulness would be 
												exploded and His truthfulness ‘a farce. Well may the child of 
												God be grateful for the fact that the Bible so 
												insistently and repeatedly 
												declares ‘the truthfulness and 
												faithfulness of God. Because God {is truthful and God is faithful 
												even finite man may come ‘to the Bible, that infinite and 
												celestial Book, knowing that if there comes to his attention 
												an apparent contradiction, pr: fancied inconsistency, that 
												it is either his own limitation, which has kept him from 
												understanding the holy Word, or else Satan himself has 
												wrought within his soul a God-denying and 
												Bible-destroying imagination. 
												Be‘cause God is true and God is 
												faithful, the Agreement Principle is wrought into the 
												very warp and woof of God's Book. 
												Passages which are cloudy 
												because of faulty translation, have become the 
												fertile soil in. which J | the enemies of the Bible have 
												produced fancied discrepancies and imaginary 
												contradictions. In view of this fact, the value 
												of the Agreement Principle becomes instantly 
												self-evident. This principle, 
												underlying the entire fabric of 
												revelation declares 
												unhesitatingly that the veracity and 
												integrity of God are the perpetual guarantee that the 
												Bible will unchangingly ‘agree with itself. Hence, when 
												an obscure passage is 
												encountered, it must never be 
												interpreted so as to contradict ‘a clear passage. To contradict 
												a clear passage with a ‘cloudy one, is to place a 
												private interpretation on the difficult passage because we 
												have the chance to do so. The Bible is delightfully definite 
												on this point: 
												 
													“Knowing this first that no 
												prophecy is of any PRIVATE INTERPRETATION.” (II 
												Pet, 1:20-21.) Surely this is final. Private 
												interpretation is forbidden. It is manifest from this passage 
												that the Holy Spirit regards a man’s private 
												interpretation as dangerous, 
												indeed so dangerous as to make it the 
												subject of a specially emphasized warming. By the Holy 
												Spirit’s thus repudiating private interpretation, it 
												becomes plain to the ‘earnest 
												and willing student that the only 
												correct interpretation of a Bible passage is the AUTHOR'S 
												INTERPRETATION. The Author of the Bible is 
												God. ‘The Bible is the sum total of His revelation. 
												Hence, the Author's notes on any given passage may 
												be found in the balance of the Scriptures. Dear 
												fellow-student, have you found an obscure passage which is 
												puzzling you? Does it seem to contradict some clear 
												passage? If this has been your experience, beware of using that 
												cloudy passage to controvert the clear one because of 
												your private interpretation ; beware of making God contradict 
												Himself; beware of such high-handed methods of 
												interpreting God’s Word. Remember because God is true and 
												God is faithful, Bible passages cannot disagree! Reject 
												your private interpretation and “search the 
												Scriptures” for God's interpretation. When you get God's light 
												on your difficult passage you will find it 
												perfectly 
												agrees with all the rest of Scripture. Blessed and happy 
												contemplation! ‘The Bible is self-interpreting and the 
												Agreement Principle never breaks down. 
												The Agreement Principle 
												Illustrated by Correct interpretation of Obscure 
												Passages 
												 A cloudy passage, the 
												interpretation of which has disturbed many of the 
												writers, is found in Rev. 5:8-10: 
													“And when he had taken the book, 
												the four beasts and four and twenty elders fell 
												down before the Lamb, having every one of them harps, 
												and golden vials full of odors, which are the prayers 
												of the saints, And they sung a new song, saying, Thou 
												art worthy to take the book, and to open the seals 
												thereof; for thou wast slain, and hast redeemed us to God by 
												thy blood out of every Kindred, and tongue, and people, 
												and nation, And hast made us unto our God kings and 
												priests: and we shall reign on the earth,” Let it be observed that both the 
												beasts (living creatures) and the four and twenty elders 
												are represented as saying “God hath redeemed US by blood.” 
												But John 3:16 declares, “God so loved the world” 
												and that only included MEN, and in Heb. 2:9 we find, 
												“He tasted death for every MAN.” Now the four living 
												creatures are shown by Ezekiel to be the four 
												cherubim and the four and twenty elders are the angelic 
												leaders of heaven's worship 
												after which was modeled David's plan 
												of twenty-four courses of priests. These four living 
												creatures are not MEN. ‘The twenty-four elders are not 
												MEN. And the record is that Jesus tasted death for 
												MEN. ‘Then why do the twenty-four elders say, “He 
												redeemed US?” ‘This apparent contradiction is 
												fully cleared up when it is learned that the word “us” 
												is not in the original text. The Revised Version gives 
												the correct translation: 
													“Thou hast redeemed MEN to God * 
												* * and hast made them unto our God kings and 
												priests and they shall reign on earth.” This translation is endorsed by 
												Tregelles, Syriac Testament, Ford C. Ottman, Pember, 
												Mofiatt, Weymouth, Rotherham, Spurgeon and jas. M. 
												Gray ‘The recognition of the correct 
												translation completely does away with the seeming 
												contradiction and the Agreement Principle is vindicated. Another passage which has been 
												pointed to as a difficult one is 
												I Cor. 3:17: 
													“If any man defile the temple of 
												God, him shall God DESTROY.” This passage does, indeed, seem 
												to contradict a truth which lies everywhere upon the 
												sacred page, the truth of the eternal security of the 
												believer. It is such passages as the following which seem to 
												be at variance with I Cor. 3:17. 
													“I give unto them eternal life 
												and they shall never perish, neither shall any man 
												pluck them out of my hand.” (Jno, 10:28.) 
													“All that the Father giveth Me 
												shall come unto Me; and him that cometh unto Me I 
												will in no wise cast out.” 
													(Jno. 6:37.) These two statements of our 
												Lord Jesus teach most clearly that when a man has once been 
												saved, his salvation is sure forever,—"I will in no wise 
												cast out.” But the Corinthian passage declares of the 
												believer who commits certain sin, “Him shall God 
												destroy.” The correct translation of 1 Cor. 
												3:17 adjusts this entire difficulty. The passage 
												should read: 
													“If any man mars the temple of 
												God, God will mar him.” Such authorities as Rotherham, 
												Weymouth and Syriac Testament agree on this 
												translation. “The message of the passage at once becomes plain. 
												If a child of God is guilty of taking his body (the temple 
												of God) into sin, that will “mar” the body and the result 
												will be that God will “mar” him. The same Greek word 
												is used in both places. When the Christian is threatened 
												with the “marring” of God, it is not destruction but 
												chastening, Every believer who sins shall be “marred,” 
												chastened, punished by God, —Whom the Lord loveth He 
												chasteneth.” And once more it is demonstrated 
												that the Bible does not contradict itself and that 
												the Agreement Principle is constantly active. Another supposed contradiction 
												appears in Revelation 20:13-14: 
													“Death and hell delivered up the 
												dead which were in them * * * Death and hell 
												were cast into the lake of fire.” This passage as it stands in our 
												Authorized Version, teaches that hell will finally 
												be depopulated. The prophecy reads, “hell delivered up 
												the dead,” and following this astonishing depopulation of 
												hell, it is predicted that hell will be cast into “the lake 
												of fire.” Now “the lake of fire” is the “everlasting 
												fire” so often spoken of by Jesus and called by Jesus “hell” 
												(gehenna). Hence, according to this translation of 
												Revelation 20:14, hell is to be cast into hell! But there is 
												still further seeming contradiction, for the Saviour in 
												speaking of hell repeatedly declares it to be the place of 
												everlasting burnings, and three times over in one 
												discourse says of it, Where 
												their worm dieth not and the fire is 
												not quenched.” The whole thought of the teaching of 
												Jesus, on this subject, is permanence and eternality. But 
												Revelation 20:1 3-14 in the Authorized Version teaches 
												that hell is only a temporary residence for the 
												unbelieving dead. Confusion could scarcely be made worse. If 
												hell is to be depopulated then it is not the place of 
												“everlasting fire,” nor is it 
												the place where “their worm dieth 
												NOT and the fire is NOT quenched.” If the Bible teaches 
												such gross contradiction as this and then adds the 
												absurdity that hell is to be 
												cast into hell, we can no longer 
												expect men to place faith in such a Book. But the solution of this enigma 
												is readily understood the moment the correct 
												translation of the Revelation 
												passage is seen: 
												 
													“Death and
													hades delivered up 
												the dead which were in them * * * Death and 
													hades were cast into the lake of fire.” It is hades which is to be 
												depopulated. Hell is not hades. Hades is the temporary 
												prison-house of the disembodied souls of the unbelieving dead. 
												Hell is the eternal torture-house of the unbelieving dead 
												after resurrection. Hades will have eventually served its 
												purpose and will be done away. Hell is never to be done 
												away. The correct translation shows conclusively that 
												this is another point where God's Word is perfect. The 
												supposed contradiction turns out to be a 
												mistranslation. The defect 
												proves to be but a human finger mark on the 
												impeccable word of God. No matter how patent a seeming 
												contradiction may be, the puzzled student of the Bible 
												may confidently apply the Agreement Principle by faith, 
												being assured that when all the facts are known the 
												integrity and perfection of the Bible will be fully vindicated. 
												The Agreement Principle 
												Illustrated by Bible ‘Testimony on Topics of Human 
												Disagreement 
												 There are certain Bible 
												subjects which have, for many years, been the centers for 
												theological wars. Because men have so completely 
												failed to agree on’ these themes they are 
												particularly valuable to use as demonstrations of the Agreement 
												Principle. The Bible testimony on these subjects, as 
												well as every other subject, is invariably harmonious and 
												complete. In such instances, the 
												hopeless confusion and 
												disagreement of men becomes the dark background which causes 
												the Divine perfection and agreement of the Scripture 
												to stand forth with special beauty and radiance. The truth about the scattering 
												of Israel and her future restoration to great glory and 
												the headship of the nations is utterly unknown to some, and 
												positively rejected by many. Writers on Bible themes 
												are utterly at variance with one another on this 
												important Bible subject. What is the teaching of God's Word on 
												the dispersion and restoration of Israel? Is it an 
												harmonious line of teaching throughout the Bible or is it, 
												like the maudlin guesses of men, self-contradictory? Let the 
												Bible speak for itself in answering this inquiry. Moses 
												wrote in Deut. 30:1-3: 
													“And it shall come to pass, when 
												all these things are come upon thee, the blessing 
												and the curse, which IT have set before thee, and 
												thou shalt call them to mind among all the nations, whither 
												the Lord thy God hath driven thee, and shalt return 
												unto the Lord thy God, and shalt obey His voice 
												according to ail that I command this day, thou and thy 
												children, with all thine heart, and with all thy 
												soul; that then the Lord thy God will turn thy captivity, 
												and have compassion upon thee, and will return and 
												gather thee from all the nations, whither the Lord thy 
												God hath scattered thee.” Notice the 
												expressions employed by the Holy 
												Spirit in this passage. They 
												fall into groups of two, and 
												each group. carries the same 
												message: 
												 
													Vs. 1—The Curse. 
													           The Blessing. 
													
													 
													Vs. 2—The Lord hath driven thee 
												* * *. 
													           Thou * * * shalt return: 
													Vs. 3—God hath scattered thee. 
													            God will turn thy captivity and 
												have compasion * * * and will return and 
												gather thee from all the nations. The explicitness of God’s Book is 
												the comfort of God's people. The Agreement Principle 
												begins to show up with astonishing clarity. The 
												dispersion and restoration of Israel are plainly and 
												repeatedly declared in this 
												portion from Deuteronomy. Do other 
												Scriptures on this subject continue this remarkable 
												agreement? 
													Isaiah 11:12 says: 
													“And He shall set up an ensign 
												for the nations, and shall assemble the outcasts 
												of Israel, and gather together the dispersed of Judah 
												from the four corners of the earth.” 
													Ezekiel 36:19 and 24 says: 
													“And I scattered them among the 
												heathens, and they were dispersed through the 
												countries * * *, For I will take you from among the 
												heathen, and gather you out of all countries, and 
												will bring you into your ‘own land.” 
													Psalms 147:2 says: 
													“The Lord doth build up 
												Jerusalem; He gathereth together the outcasts of 
												Israel.” 
													 
													Jeremiah 23:3 says: 
													“And I will gather the remnant 
												of my flock out of all countries whither I have 
												driven them, and will bring them again to their folds; and 
												they shall be fruitful and increase.” 
													Amos 9214-15 says: 
													“And I will bring again the 
												captivity of my people of Israel, and they 
													shall build 
												the waste cities, and inhabit them; and they shall 
												plant vineyards, and ‘drink the wine thereof; they shall 
												also make gardens, and eat the fruit of them. And I will 
												plant them upon their land, and they shall no more be 
												pulled up out of their land which I have given them, 
												saith the Lord thy God.” 
													
													 
													Romans 11:25-26 says: 
													“For I would not, brethren, that 
												ye should be ignorant of this mystery, lest ye 
												should be wise in your own, conceits; that blindness in part 
												is happened to Israel, until the fulness of the 
												Gentiles be come in. And so all Israel shall be saved; as it 
												is written, ‘There shall come out of Sion the Deliverer, 
												and shall turn away ungodliness from Jacob.” Agreement! ‘There is naught but 
												agreement. Moses and Isaiah, Ezekiel and the 
												Psalmist, Jeremiah and Amos, 
												yes, and even Paul, join in one 
												united testimony of God’s judgment and God's blessing of 
												future restoration on Israel. The separation of many 
												centuries does not interfere with Biblical agreement for 
												there is one Mind Who is the source of all Scripture. 
												Vast differences of training in the lives of the writers do 
												not hinder agreement because “all Scripture is given by 
												inspiration of God.” ‘The very subject upon which human minds 
												fumble and fall and become enmeshed in controversy 
												is the theme upon which God delights to exhibit the 
												matchless beauty and doctrinal perfection of His inspired Word. 
												From Genesis to Revelation the Agreement Principle 
												is active in the Bible. Here is a powerful key which 
												when placed in the hands of faith, will unlock to 
												the willing soul the richest treasures of God's unmeasured 
												grace and deliver intact every promise and precept of the 
												Book of books. 
												Copyright 1923, Clifton L. 
												Fowler | ||
| 
 | ||
 Home
 
				  			
						Home What's New
   
							
						What's New Bible
   
							
						Bible Photos
 	
							
						Photos Hiking
  
						 	
						Hiking E-Books
   
							
						E-Books Genealogy
  
							
						Genealogy Profile
 
						Profile Get Java
   
				  			Get Java.png) Get Flash
   
							
						Get Flash Get 7-Zip
   
							Get 7-Zip Get Acrobat Reader
   
							
						Get Acrobat Reader Get TheWORD
   
							Get TheWORD